Best Pizza Slice in NYC – Full List

How good is a pizza slice in NYC? Well, it’s amazing, isn’t it, but only if you know where to go.

As with anything, you have good pizza places and poor pizza places. Sadly, those poor places can destroy your relationship with pizza. So, we want to help you avoid those pizzerias that don’t do justice to pizza.

But the problem here is that NYC has more than its fair share of places where you can go ahead and purchase a pizza slice. We have included only the best shops we think you should check out.

We don’t have an overall favorite out of these names, so we suggest you go ahead and check out each one on our list. 

With that in mind, let’s get on with the list of places that offer the best pizza slice in NYC.

NY Pizza Suprema

ny pizza suprema

Founded in 1964, NY Pizza Suprema has long been viewed as one of the best places for a pizza slice in NYC. Located on 8th Avenue close to Madison Square Gardens.

You would be hard-pressed to find someone in NYC that doesn’t know about this pizzeria.

They offer pizza both by the slice and as a whole and have many options for toppings.

You can either dine in, take away, or even get a delivery, so there’s no reason not to check out the pizza they offer.

What you get here is a crispy crust every time, and saying this pizza blows your mind from a taste perspective is an understatement.

There’s a reason why it has remained so popular over the decades, and it’s all thanks to the quality of its pizza.

But people also comment on the variety of slices available. They use amazing ingredients, and there is no way you will ever walk away from NY Pizza Suprema without a smile on your face and a very happy belly.

NY Pizza Suprema managed to raise the bar when it came to the slice, and if you find yourself at the Gardens for any reason, then shoot across the road and see why people love this place so much.

Scarr’s Pizza

You know a pizzeria has established itself when it can start offering merchandise along with its pizza slices.

That’s the case here with Scarr’s Pizza; if you aren’t sure where it’s located, you will find them on Orchard Street.

It’s not only the quality of the slices that we love here but also the prices per slice.

They remain out of this world, and you get a quality crust, and fresh toppings just come across as a real bonus.

You will also find that they don’t mess around when serving people. You may have to wait five minutes, but that’s nothing when you see how popular it is.

But back to the slice. What you get here is a pizza slice that always seems to strike that balance between the amount of sauce and the amount of cheese.

One always compliments the other, and then the other toppings simply add a little bit extra to proceedings.

Overall, we know you will love the pizza slice options at Scarr’s Pizza. The only problem is trying to find where to begin when it comes to the first slice you plan to order.

Corner Slice

corner slice

What we love about Corner Slice is the way they focus entirely on producing the best slices that money can buy. Located on 11th Avenue at W. 45th Street, they focus on producing authentic slices that will leave you wanting more.

Based at Gotham West Market, you will not find anything too fancy or elaborate here, but they don’t need to do that. Instead, they let their slices do the talking for them, and boy, they do a lot of talking.

They make everything fresh, and when you order to go and pick it up, they will warm it up right there in front of you. That’s why this has become one of the go-to places for people who want to grab a quick bite to eat and then move on with their lives. 

You will need to take time to work through their options because they have so many of them. Of course, you could stick with the authentic and original slice, and if you do, we know you will love it.

They give you a crust with enough crunch, ample cheese, and enough tomato sauce without going over the top. Also, you will enjoy the balance of flavors throughout your slice, and it’s obvious they use quality ingredients.

Overall, Corner Slice shows you can keep things basic if your pizza does the talking for you.

Koronet Pizza

If you want to go to a pizza place that offers you an impressive size of the slice, then Koronet Pizza needs to appear on your list. Located at Broadway, they offer what they describe as king-size slices, and they won’t disappoint.

You have the option of dining in, delivery or takeaway, but we figure that as long as you taste their pizza, who cares how you gain access to it?

The irony is that this place is not the biggest when it comes to the location, so it’s strange they then produce some of the biggest slices you will see around. Also, they do hit you with a lot of flavor, so you must prepare yourself for that.

We need to mention their ratios as well. A good slice must get the ratio between crust, cheese, and sauce perfect for it all to work. Well, Koronet Pizza does that and a whole lot more on top.

Overall, you get friendly service from helpful staff, but make sure you feel hungry before you tackle their slice as it’s huge. However, we do not doubt you will feel more than satisfied once it’s all over.

Louie & Ernie’s Pizza

If you want somewhere traditional with a slice, Louie & Ernie’s Pizza in the Bronx is one of the best. This name has been around since 1947, when it was based in Harlem, before moving to its current location in 1959.

Of course, the original Louie & Ernie will no longer be with us, but the name carries on for a good reason. 

Known for producing the best slice in the Bronx, this establishment produces quality crusts that will burst open your taste buds at the first bite.

Also, their tomato sauce comes packed with flavor, and they also make sure that they don’t put too much on that it changes the taste.

But we love the authenticity of the slice here. It’s a tried and tested recipe that always hits the mark, and there’s no way you will ever feel disappointed.

Pizza Barn

pizza barn slice

Located on Central Park Avenue in Yonkers, Pizza Barn can turn your love of pizza into an addiction.

Known as the home of the super slice, you better not eat anything for a while before you go here, or you may struggle to finish that single slice.

This veteran Italian restaurant knows a thing or two about making pizza, which will become obvious from the moment you take your first bite.

After all, they have been making pizza since 1975, so you can only imagine the huge number of happy customers they have had since then.

So, just how big is their super slice? Well, it’s 2ft, so you can see why we tell you that you need to feel hungry before tackling it.

Also, we think you should check out the menu options for the toppings, as you have so many to choose from.

Overall, Pizza Barn manages to turn this into an experience, and if you don’t feel like going, they also offer delivery.

However, their establishment is such a cool place that we think you should check it out in person to see what all the fuss is about.

Our Conclusion

And those are the places offering the best pizza slice in NYC, and we know you will look at this list and realize you have too many to choose from. So, take the sensible option and go ahead and check out each establishment that appears on our list.

By doing so, at least you can try several different slices, and perhaps you can conclude who is the best in NYC.

With so many options available, we reckon if you try each one on our list, then you will know exactly where you need to go to satisfy your craving for a slice.